Eagle Bulk in trend-setting equity for debt exchange

After the TORM restructuring earlier this year, we now see another “equity for debt” exchange deal between Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) and its beleaguered client, Eagle Bulk Shipping (EGLE).  RBS takes warrants for conversion into a 19.99% stake in EGLE.  To reduce the effects of dilution on shareholders, only one third of the shares can be cashed immediately.  There are share price triggers of US$ 10 and 12 per share for the cash out of the remaining shares in two tranches.  This sort of deal sets a new precedent for the shipping industry to keep weak companies alive a significant runway for a market recovery.

EGLE is carrying a crushing US$ 1.2 billion debt load, which was the result of massive block deal to expand its fleet at the peak of the boom cycle. As many shipping companies prior the 2008 financial crisis, EGLE preferred to expand its fleet by paying a premium to a private shipping company for a package deal rather than generating directly its own business for added value. The deal resulted in higher term debt leverage. Then with deteriorating market conditions, the company faced declining hull values and asset impairment charges as well as loan covenant violations as vessel values dropped below hull coverage ratios. The last two years, EGLE has been plagued with charter party defaults, declining revenues, growing operating losses. It is a highly leveraged player at the wrong time and place of the cycle.

This year, EGLE has seen considerable press about protracted negotiations with its senior lenders. Recently, EGLE and RBS settled a dispute over defaults to the huge loan and won a repayment holiday into 2015. The bank also offered up a new facility to the tune of US$ 20 million. An integral part of the deal was that the RBS would take a substantial equity share in the company as detailed above.

Doug Mavrinac of Jefferies was reportedly ebullient about the deal :

“Given that EGLE shares are effectively a call option at current levels, we believe the agreement is very attractive as it significantly lengthens the runway time for the market to improve and removes bankruptcy risk over the medium term,” he added:

“We also believe the move has positive implications for other large dry bulk shipowners regarding the banks' willingness to work through debt issues.”

Whilst I would agree that this deal sets a useful precedent for other troubled owners, I am not so sure that it is as beneficial to shareholders as he describes. I find this a bit like having your cake and eating it, too.

Inevitably, no one is going to come out whole in this unless the dry bulk markets improve, the company becomes profitable again, debt is paid down and vessel values rise. The Chinese growth cycle in infrastructure investment seems to be at an end. There are far too many ships. Scrap and steel prices are falling. There is a potential issue about new ship designs with lower fuel consumption.

EGLE remains badly exposed due to bad investment decisions of the past. Not only has management failed in delivering value to shareholders, but there have also been concerns about continued high remuneration levels despite the poor results. Added to this, the lenders now have an equity share in the upside, which means less to other common shareholders.

With Supramax rate expectations of US$11,000 per day on average the outlook still looks challenging. Prior this restructuring agreement, even market improvement expectations of US$ 13,000 perday for spot earnings in 2013 were not sufficient to service the crushing US$ 108 million debt maturities falling due.

So is EGLE an attractive company to buy as opposed to invest in peer dry bulk companies with better management performance, market position, lower leverage and healthier financial results?  Probably not!

EGLE is going to have to prove itself to be credible again.  This will take time and luck.